Franklin Graham has described socialism as the “Gospel of envy”—a “bankrupt ideology” that promises a feast and delivers crumbs. As the appeal for socialism has dramatically risen across America, Christians and conservatives have tirelessly warned about what dangers could await the country should it embrace socialist, soft-on-crime and other left-wing policies.
In New York City, with socialist Muslim Mayor Zohran Mamdani making major moves since taking office in January, many of these warnings are already coming to fruition. The feast of “equity” and “safety” is being served as a thin gruel of reduced policing, delayed accountability, and housing policies that leave buildings rotting.
Softening The Streets, Softening The Cells
This week alone, Mamdani made two major announcements related to how NYC will handle crime, criminals and civil unrest—moves that explicitly portray law enforcement as the problem and detention as the greater injustice.
On Monday, Mamdani said that the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG) would be disbanded. Formed in 2015, SRG has been responsible for counterterrorism and critical infrastructure, major emergencies and mass-casualty incidents, crowd and protest control, and patrol support and street-crime surges. The unit is being replaced by a civilian-led “Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division” with no weapons or arrest powers, alongside new NYPD teams focused on dialogue rather than deterrent-driven responses.
The move was largely celebrated by the same groups that have regularly protested against ICE, Israel, capitalism and American exceptionalism. The Party for Socialism and Liberation—a protest network of activists—posted on X that dismantling this police unit was a win for “the mass movement” while emphasizing that “the fight continues.”
Self-declared Marxist influencer and Twitch streamer Hasan Piker also chimed in, saying he was “glad” to hear of the disbanding of the counterterrorism group. Anti-Israel activist Nerdeen Kiswani likewise shared his opinion that the disbanding of SRG is “overdue and welcome news.”
James Gagliano, a retired FBI supervisory special agent who spent years working with the NYPD, shared a different perspective: “I think it’s one more step towards emboldening the criminals, emboldening the anarchists and emboldening the terrorists.”
And yet, only days later, Mamdani announced the impending closure of Rikers Island jail complex—one of the largest local jail systems in the U.S. It opened in 1932, and roughly 85% of those held there are pretrial detainees, meaning they’re awaiting trial or sentencing. The rest are serving shorter sentences that are approximately one year or less or are awaiting transfer to state custody.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement. “For decades, New Yorkers have demanded a correctional system that is safe and humane.” He detailed his administration’s plan to have the facility completely shut down by 2032—delaying the prior legal deadline of 2027—which includes cutting down on the number of those incarcerated—something observers have warned could mean releasing criminals back into society. Mamdani also said he wants new jails that are more comfortable and pleasing, describing them as facilities that “will serve as hubs for community.”
Under Mamdani’s X post alone, which was how he announced this plan, were oodles of comments full of concerns and questions. The John Birch Society, a conservative advocacy organization, wrote that “NYC really is the best picture we have of managed decline.”
The Rent Control Reckoning
Socialist housing policies often offer a freeze on or tightly controlled rents so “greedy landlords” can’t charge too much and tenants get relief. But in practice, critics argue, they punish anyone who owns and maintains buildings. When owners can’t charge enough to cover rising costs, they may stop investing, leading to leaky roofs, heat failures, elevator breaks, and eventually buildings going under completely.
This is what’s happening in New York right now.
In East Harlem, a large group of rent-stabilized buildings (former Emerald Equities properties) hit the foreclosure auction block. The Mamdani administration had said it would stop these kinds of sales and keep the housing “affordable” under community or nonprofit control. Specifically to scare off private investors, tenants organized rent strikes and a “buyer beware” campaign hoping a nonprofit or community land trust would step in.
Instead, of 27 buildings put up for auction, 26 got no bids at all and were handed back to the creditor for $500 each. The city’s attempt to back a preferred “preservation” buyer was rejected because the offers were far too low to cover what the bank was owed. Tenants are now stuck with a court-appointed receiver and buildings that still need basic repairs—doors, ceilings, heat and gas.
Finance commentator Paula Pant summed it up on X: the tenants ran their campaign, hoped for a nonprofit rescue, and instead watched the buildings fail to sell while “there’s no money” for the fixes they need.
The Feast Of Crumbs
These are early snapshots of the ideology Franklin Graham warned against—the Gospel of envy that pits class against class, promises abundance through redistribution and reduced enforcement, and then watches order and maintenance crumble.
As Franklin explained, “This is precisely why Christians must base their vote on Biblical values by supporting political candidates who recognize the sanctity of human life and Biblical marriage between a man and a woman; national borders and law enforcement; and the value of work and productivity. Socialism seeks to undermine all of this.”
Many are left wondering if New York is offering a real-time case study in what that undermining looks like.





















